Arethusa Farm Dairy, Bantam, CT

Milk Like It Used to Taste

  • Arethusa Farm Dairy
  • Arethusa Farm Dairy
  • Arethusa Farm Dairy

About Arethusa Farm Dairy

In 1996 two ex-executive at Manolo Blahnik footwear, Anthony Yugaitis and George Makelmus purchased a century old horse farm across the road from their home in Litchfield, CT, and decided to revive the original dairy that stood in that spot a century before. They started out selling milk from their herd of Jersey, Brown Swiss, and Holstein cows which later evolved into a cheese-making venture. They use only milk from their highly pampered, purebred cows. They pride themselves on providing the absolute highest level of care for their animals and like to say “Great milk comes from great cows, and great cows come from Arethusa”.
Arethusa Blue is their take on classic British-style blue cheeses like Stilton. Extra cream is added to raise the butterfat content and the wheels are pierced once during their 3-4 month aging process.
The result is a bright, sweet, and a bit tangy cheese with a good salt balance. Notes of wet hay, chocolate, toasted butter, and vegetal notes are laced throughout. Arethusa is a unique and very easy-eating blue, wonderful on a dessert plate or with a stout or smoked porter.

 

Arethusa Farm Dairy

"We’re making milk the way we used to — vat pasteurized — but doing it in a very sophisticated way."

Chris Casiello, Seasoned Dairy Producer

IN SEASON NOW

From Arethusa Farm Dairy

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Sour Cream

PAMILKAR6
6 X 16 OZ
Sour Cream
Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Plain Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR1
6 X 32 OZ
Plain Yogurt

CUSTOM HARVEST PRODUCTS

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Whole Milk

PAMILKAR1
9 X 1/2 GAL
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Whole Milk
back

Whole Milk

PAMILKAR1


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Vanilla Whole Milk Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR4
12 X 6 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Vanilla Whole Milk Yogurt
back

Vanilla Whole Milk Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR4


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Maple Whole Milk Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR3
12 X 6 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Maple Whole Milk Yogurt
back

Maple Whole Milk Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR3


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Low Fat Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR2
6 X 32 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Low Fat Yogurt
back

Low Fat Yogurt

PAYOGURTAR2


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Half & Half

PAMILKAR99
16 X 32 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Half & Half
back

Half & Half

PAMILKAR99


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR9
16 X 32 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Chocolate Milk
back

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR9


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR8
9 X 64 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Chocolate Milk
back

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR8


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Skim Milk

PAMILKAR7
9 X 64 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Skim Milk
back

Skim Milk

PAMILKAR7


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

1% Milk

PAMILKAR66
9 X 64 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
1% Milk
back

1% Milk

PAMILKAR66


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR4
12 X 16 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Chocolate Milk
back

Chocolate Milk

PAMILKAR4


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Whole Milk

PAMILKAR3
12 X 16 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Whole Milk
back

Whole Milk

PAMILKAR3


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

2% Milk

PAMILKAR2
9 X 1/2 GAL
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
2% Milk
back

2% Milk

PAMILKAR2


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Arethusa Diva

PACHEESE10AD
6 X 8 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Arethusa Diva
back

Arethusa Diva

PACHEESE10AD


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Tapping Reeve Wheel

PACHEESE10TRW
15 LB AVG
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Tapping Reeve Wheel
back

Tapping Reeve Wheel

PACHEESE10TRW


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Tapping Reeve Retail

PACHEESE10TR
12 X 5.5 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Tapping Reeve Retail
back

Tapping Reeve Retail

PACHEESE10TR


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Karlies Gratitude

PACHEESE10KG
6 X 8 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Karlies Gratitude
back

Karlies Gratitude

PACHEESE10KG


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Europa Wheel

PACHEESE10EUR
18 LB AVG
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Europa Wheel
back

Europa Wheel

PACHEESE10EUR


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Europa Cheese

PACHEESE10EU
12 X 5.5 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Europa Cheese
back

Europa Cheese

PACHEESE10EU


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Camembert

PACHEESE10CR
6 X 8 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Camembert
back

Camembert

PACHEESE10CR


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Crybaby Retail

PACHEESE10CBR
12 X 5.5 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Crybaby Retail
back

Crybaby Retail

PACHEESE10CBR


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Crybaby Wheel

PACHEESE10CB
18 LB AVG
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Crybaby Wheel
back

Crybaby Wheel

PACHEESE10CB


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Bella Bantam Retail

PACHEESE10BBR
12 X 5.5 OZ
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Bella Bantam Retail
back

Bella Bantam Retail

PACHEESE10BBR


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Bella Bantam Wheel

PACHEESE10BB
15.8 LB AVG
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Bella Bantam Wheel
back

Bella Bantam Wheel

PACHEESE10BB


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.

Add To Cart
Add
Add To Cart
Add To Cart View Cart
local
ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY

Arethusa Blue Wheel

PACHEESE10B
8 LB AVG
Preorder item.
Click here
for ordering info.
Jun 30
Arethusa Blue Wheel
back

Arethusa Blue Wheel

PACHEESE10B


This product requires a 6 day lead time. Please be sure to place your order 6 days before your desired delivery date.